Managing Fleet Insurance Claims: A Step-by-Step Guide
Unfortunately, no matter how safe our vehicles are, how well-trained our drivers are, and how carefully we operate, fleet insurance and the insurance claims process are going to be part of operations. Human error, freak accidents, and other drivers; there are many possible causes of accidents and collisions, and that’s where fleet insurance comes into play.
There’s an understandable urge amongst fleet managers to aim to cut costs in any way possible, and often, fleet insurance is on the chopping block. Whether you’ve gone months or years without an issue, it can feel like dialing back on insurance coverage is a good idea. Unfortunately, when something inevitably does happen, and you need to file a claim, cheaper and less robust insurance is going to come back to bite you.
Picking the right level of coverage and the right insurance provider for your fleet – and for each vehicle in your fleet – is a complex decision of its own. You can learn more about that aspect here.
If and when a collision occurs, and you need to file an insurance claim against your fleet insurance, how do you do it? Let’s go through the process.
Disclaimer
Before we dig in too deep, it’s worth mentioning that the information in this post is, by necessity, somewhat generic. Different insurance providers will have different specific processes you’ll need to follow. The steps required, who you talk to, the portals you use, and the information you gather may be different, depending.
Always check with your insurance company and learn their process and how it differs from the generic process we describe here.
Step 1: Know What’s Covered
The first thing you want to do is understand what is and isn’t covered by your insurance. It does you no good to try to file a claim for reimbursement for, say, vandalism if your insurance coverage doesn’t actually protect you from vandalism.
Usually, basic fleet insurance will cover personal injury, property damage, equipment damage, and cargo damage. It will often have limits that may not reach the extent of the damage done, though that depends on the policy you have.
More advanced and comprehensive coverage may be unlimited, may cover other damage, and can potentially even cover things like vandalism, random acts of nature like storm damage, or even theft.
Some states mandate different levels of coverage. Depending on where you operate, you may be required to carry at least some minimum amount of coverage or more comprehensive coverage. Knowing what is and isn’t covered specifically in your policy will allow you to file all of the relevant information to make sure your claim is processed properly.
Step 2: Contact Your Insurance Agent
Any time there’s an incident that will need an insurance claim, your order of operations should be:
- Contact emergency response. This is essential for a police report, for EMS in case of bodily injury, and to give specific information about hazardous materials that may be involved in the collision.
- Contact your insurance agent to inform them of an issue and get the process started for filing an insurance claim.
- Contact tow services and shops if necessary to have the involved vehicle moved to a safe location.
You need to contact your insurance agent as soon as possible, but always prioritize the safety and health of your drivers and anyone else involved first.
There’s a decent chance that you’ll need a police report for the incident to file your insurance claim, and your insurance provider may have specific nearby facilities that they work with for damage assessment and insurance adjustment. It’s an additional delay, hassle, and expense if you don’t know where you send your vehicle after an accident, so make sure you talk to your agent right away.
Step 3: Gather Information
Your next step in the process is to gather all of the relevant information. This is where your insurance agent will also come in handy because they will likely have a checklist and form for you to fill out, which will tell you everything you need.
In general, be prepared to gather and hand over:
- Your driver’s license to operate the commercial vehicle involved.
- Your insurance policy’s number and start/end dates.
- License and/or VIN numbers for the vehicles involved.
- Basic information about the incident, including where it happened, when, and what occurred.
- A copy of the police report for the incident.
- Photographs of the scene and the damage.
- Contact information for any witnesses willing to be involved.
- Any other details that can shed light on what happened.
- Special note: If you have maintenance records for the state of the vehicle prior to the trip, gather those as well, just in case.
In some cases, you may have special information, or you may not be able to get all of the relevant information. For example, if a vehicle is vandalized in your yard and no driver is involved, their license isn’t relevant. At the same time, something like security camera footage may be much more valuable and accessible.
Step 4: Keep Records
During this claims process, you will also need to be keeping records of your own. Keep copies of every piece of information you hand over to the insurance company so you have your own records of the incident. Further, keep track of the dates you submit everything and all communication back and forth with any parties involved.
All of these records are part of covering your bases in case there’s ever an argument or disconnect with the claims process. You want records of the details of an incident in case someone tries to change a story later. You want records of when the paperwork was submitted and when communication happened in case anything gets lost. You want to be able to cover yourself in the event of any accidental or intentional tampering, rare though it may be.
If you’re using modern fleet management software, there’s likely a feature you can use for claims management. You may need to configure the system and learn how to use it, but it can be a great place for a central record store for everything related to any given incident.
Step 5: Address Medical Issues Immediately
When handling the repercussions and fallout of any accident, you need to make sure the people involved are okay. While it’s not really your responsibility to see to any other parties involved in an accident, your driver needs to be referred to a check-up for anything more than a minor fender-bender. Fleet vehicles are generally pretty safe, especially from things like whiplash, but high-speed and high-damage incidents, roll-overs, and other significant collisions can lead to serious medical complications.
More importantly, a collision is going to get the adrenaline pumping, and while your driver might feel fine at the moment, they may have injuries that won’t reveal themselves for days afterward. Getting your driver to see a doctor for a quick check-up will help ensure that any medical issues are addressed right away.
While an insurance company has the power to decide what shop or inspection you take your vehicle to before they cover authorized repairs, they don’t have the same authority over driver medical care. Don’t wait for approval; get your driver seen, and keep records of any injuries that may need to be part of the insurance coverage.
Step 6: Wait for an Adjuster to Inspect Vehicle Damage
Unfortunately, you can’t just have your truck towed to a nearby repair facility, have it fixed up, and bill insurance later. Your insurance company will want to send a claims adjuster out, who will inspect the damage and determine what they’ll cover and to what extent. They will also likely be looking for ways to exclude certain repairs from being covered or reasons to deny a claim entirely. Sadly, insurance companies aren’t generally in it for your best interests.
This is part of why having good proactive maintenance in place is essential. If your truck slides on a slick road surface and rear-ends a smaller vehicle, and the insurance adjuster finds that your tires were low on tread and out of spec, they could use that to justify dramatically cutting or denying your claim entirely.
Work with your insurance agent to know where to send your vehicle for this inspection. Sometimes, the mechanics at the shop can do it, and other times, you may need to wait for a third party. Either way, don’t expect your truck to be back in service on a scale of days. Weeks, or even months, is more likely.
Step 7: Authorize and Perform Repairs
You are not required to use the shop that your insurance provider works with, but there are benefits to doing so. They have better communication with the insurance company than a third-party shop would, so there will be fewer delays. However, the insurance provider may work with them because they do inexpensive work, which may not be up to your standards. You have to choose where to have your truck repaired, and make sure to communicate about the necessary and covered repairs, gather quotes, and have work authorized for reimbursement.
One note to make here is that if the insurance company seems to be dragging its feet, or the shop isn’t on the up and up, or if you have any other concerns, you should bring them up and see if they can be resolved. In some cases, you may want to seek out an independent appraisal of the damage and the necessary repairs.
Unfortunately, if there’s a conflict between what you perceive to be reality and necessary repairs due to damage from an accident, the insurance company isn’t likely to just fold over. This is where you may need to get an attorney involved.
Working with lawyers to deal with the aftermath of a fleet vehicle accident is never fun, but sometimes it’s necessary. Having someone who knows fleet and automotive law on your side, working on your behalf, is a great asset.
This is also where all of those records you’ve kept come in. If a lawyer can view all of these records and find that your insurance company has been in the wrong, they can lay down the pressure or threaten a lawsuit that can get the company to comply.
Step 8: Implement Preventative Policies and Maintenance if Necessary
At this point, the process should be more or less over. You’ll need to have work done to finish repairing your vehicle, and you’ll need to submit the final costs and get your reimbursement, but otherwise, everything is in order. Or, of course, the worst case has happened, and you’re involved in a legal battle.
Either way, this is where any roadblocks, flaws, or issues in your fleet management will have been drawn into stark contrast. For example, if it was a huge pain to gather all of the information about the driver and vehicle in order to submit your claim, you should see if there’s an easier way to keep all of that information on hand. Most fleet management apps these days allow you to store and update all of that information, so make use of those features.
Similarly, the process of having your vehicle reviewed by a claims adjuster can showcase any issues you may have with your inspection and maintenance policies. It can expose gaps or flaws in your maintenance but also in your driver training and reporting. If drivers haven’t been adequately inspecting their vehicles, that can cause problems.
This is your opportunity to reevaluate and reimplement any of these policies before something else happens, and you need to go through the entire process again.
Step 9: Implement Fleet Claim Management if Necessary
At the same time, fleet management apps often have a claims management module built into them. This can make it dramatically easier to gather relevant information, store records, and generate reports all in one place. If you don’t have such a system set up, it’s likely a good idea to do so.
Finally, if you need to have a network of service providers for maintenance and repairs on hand, we’re a great option. Our nationwide network of service providers is here to help you get everything going right, from the first mile to the millionth mile and beyond. Interested? It’s easy to find a service provider.